Back
 
"The Babe Ruth of His Day"
  By H. Scott Wolfe
  In the old days, baseball could be a game of trickery. So it was when a smoky haze swept the diamond in Buffalo, New York. The bases were loaded and two men were out, when the batter lofted a fly ball toward Dalrymple in left. The agile outfielder made the leaping "catch", preserving his team’s victory. Only later was it revealed that the ball had actually cleared the smoke-shrouded fence—and Dalrymple had replaced it with one conveniently hidden in the blouse of his uniform. It was the talk of the baseball world for years.

* * * * * * * * * *

Abner Frank Dalrymple was born on September 19, 1857 near Gratiot, Wisconsin, the son of New York-born auctioneer Samuel L. Dalrymple. By the early 1860s, the family had removed across the State line, to Warren, Illinois. This growing community, astride the tracks of the Illinois Central, was to nurture the twin passions of young Abner— railroading and baseball. Both of his future careers were to be rooted in Jo Daviess County.

Abner attended the Warren grade school and took on odd jobs to help support his family. He also joined the local baseball team, immediately showing great promise as both a hitter and fielder.  At the tender age of 14, he was hired by the Illinois Central as a substitute brakeman—not because of his potential skill at this profession, but because the railroad had organized a ball club in Amboy, Illinois. After three years, it became apparent that Dalrymple’s own abilities as a baseball player far eclipsed those of his fellow workers. He began playing for more established teams in Freeport, Illinois and Janesville and Milwaukee, Wisconsin. And while playing at the latter place, Abner Dalrymple’s dream was realized—the major leagues!

The National League, created in 1876, had a new member—the Milwaukee Cream Citys—and in 1878 Abner Dalrymple became their left fielder. And this, his rookie season, made him a star. He was among the top ten players in the league in nine offensive categories—and was credited with the 1878 batting crown, hitting a robust .354. Called "the demon hitter of his time", his performance resulted in a spirited bidding war, as virtually every team sought his services for the 1879 season. A $2,500 offer sent Dalrymple to the Chicago White Stockings—beginning an association that would last an exciting eight years.

A young Abner as a Chicago White Stocking.

Player/Manager Cap Anson’s White Stockings were to be the team of the next decade, winning five National League pennants in seven seasons (1880-82, 1885-86). And the club’s leadoff hitter—the man to ignite their offense—was left fielder Abner Dalrymple. Four times "Dal" paced the league in at-bats. In 1880, he led in runs, hits and total bases, while batting a splendid .330. In one game that year against Worcester, Dalrymple and two of his teammates, normally all left-handed batters, switched over to the right side—each collecting a hit in a 4-0 triumph. In 1883, Dalrymple and Anson (a future Hall of Famer) each collected five hits in a 31-7 demolition of Buffalo. In that game, the blistering White Stockings collected a major league record fourteen doubles, four by Dalrymple himself.

And "Dal" could hit for power. In 1884 Abner socked 22 home runs for a Chicago team that, thanks to a short right field fence, totaled 140—a single season record that stood until the 1927 Yankees hit 158. His 11 homers in 1885 led the league. As Dalrymple continued to excel, his salary rose accordingly. At his professional peak, the White Stockings paid him the astronomical sum of $300 per month—an extraordinary amount for the time. And he traveled the country with some equally famous teammates—including Anson, the first player to amass 3000 hits; and fellow outfielder, and speedy base stealer, Billy Sunday, who would one day make a career of evangelism. Abner Dalrymple had journeyed far from Warren, Illinois and substitute railroad brakeman.

Following the 1886 season, when he hit a disappointing .233, Dalrymple was sold to another team—the Pittsburgh Alleghenys. It was written that "life never seemed the same to the old crowd of rooters at Harrison and Loomis streets in Chicago." In 1887, four images of the famous left fielder appeared on tobacco trading cards advertising "Old Judge Cigarettes" showing an athlete in the waning days of his prime. Mainly due to illness, his batting average continued to decline during his two year stint in Pittsburgh.

After years with Denver and Milwaukee of the Western Association, "Dal" got his final chance in the big leagues in 1891. The American Association had a new team, the Milwaukee Brewers, a late season replacement for the departing Cincinnati Porkers. And Abner immediately became the fan favorite. In this, his farewell season, he hit an admirable .311. His career had come full circle—beginning and ending in Milwaukee.

Trading card of Abner as a member of the Pittsburgh Alleghenys.

On January 24, 1892, Abner re-entered railroad service—becoming a passenger conductor for the Northern Pacific line. But he obtained a ninety day leave of absence each summer for four seasons—finishing out his career in Spokane, Washington; Macon, Georgia; Indianapolis and Evansville, Indiana. His last appearance on the field, at the age of 50, was with a semi-pro team in Grand Forks, North Dakota in 1907.

On September 20, 1926, Abner returned to his boyhood home of Warren, Illinois to marry Mrs. Margaret Alderson Glasgow. The bride had a "beautifully and artistically furnished" bungalow there, where the couple spent the summer months prior to Abner’s retirement from the Northern Pacific in 1928.

And on January 25, 1939, Abner Dalrymple died at his home in Warren. He was buried in Elmwood Cemetery, within earshot of the train whistles so inspiring during his youth. In September of that year, a "unique marker" was placed on the grave. The J.P. Vincent & Sons Monument Works of Galena had created a granite stone, in the center of which is the image of a left-handed batter. And the inscription includes: Chicago White Stockings, 1879-1886.

Abner’s memory lives on. As does his team—now known as the Chicago Cubs.

 


 

 

The Museum . History Highlights . The Gift Shop . Tours/Events . Blacksmith Shop . Membership . Links . Home


Copyright ©1999 Galena Historical Society. All rights reserved.